I didn't know what the day was 
 I didn't know what time it was 
 I didn't know what my heart would do 
 I was afraid of nothing when you called me on the telephone 
 I was creature of appetites 
 We played a game that you didn't like 
 There wasn't nothing that I couldn't do 
 I can be so bad, 
 I can be so bad 
 just took it away and we broke it in two 
    Color my heart, color my heart 
 Make it restart, make it restart 
 Color my heart, I want it more than I ever knew 
 The blackest lily, the blackest pony 
 Won't protect my heart from you   
 You were unnerving and delicate 
 And I weakness for etiquette 
 You laid a trail that led straight to your door 
 And I could resist but it was hard to endure   
 Color my heart, color my heart 
 Make it restart, make it restart 
 Color my heart, I want it more than I ever knew 
 The blackest lily, the blackest pony 
 Won't protect my heart from you   
 I didn't know what the day it was 
 I didn't know what the time it was 
 I didn't know what my heart would do 
 And I was afraid of nothing when you called me on the telephone   
 Color my heart, color my heart 
 Make it restart, make it restart 
 Color my heart, I want it more than I ever knew 
 The blackest lily, the blackest pony 
 Won't protect my heart from you