Holding hands in the dark 
 We were scared to let this start 
 Now we're afraid to let it go 
 Tell me what's on your heart 
 She said boy you'd be smart 
 To kiss me now before you never know 
    I nervously reach for the dial 
 She said "Don't change it now, I love this song. It reminds me of you" 
 I tried to hide a smile 
 And I tried to figure out how I've gone this long 
 And what I'd do to   
 Keep you right where you are 
 It's perfect when you're next to me in the car 
 Keep you right where you are 
 Filling and spilling our hearts, holding hands in the dark   
 Moonlight on the dashboard 
 Turns into a dance floor 
 Just for me and you 
 I don't know when you'll have to leave 
 But I know you will eventually 
 And it's a quarter to two   
 You nervously reach for your phone 
 I said "Don't call them now. Just one more song that reminds me of you" 
 You tried to hide a smile 
 And you tried to figure out 
 If I want what you want 
 And I do, and now I need to   
 Keep you right where you are 
 It's perfect when you're next to me in the car 
 Keep you right where you are 
 Filling and spilling our hearts 
 Holding hands   
 Everything you said is like a script in my head 
 That I read all day 
 And every minute that we spent is like a movie I can rent 
 And I love to push play 
 Rewind it over again   
 And keep you right where you are 
 You know it's perfect when you're next to me   
 Keep you right where you are 
 Filling and spilling our hearts 
 Keep you right where you are 
 It's perfect when you're next to me in the car 
 Keep you right where you are 
 Filling and spilling our hearts 
 Holding hands in the dark