Pitch black when I try to look back 
 The entire history of you 
 And the bad moves we outgrew 
 Selective aphantasia 
 Charlie Kaufmann box office smash 
 Where the Montauk waves crash 
    Yeah, yeah yeah   
 If you could keep a secret 
 I would bring this moment to the grave 
 Take the time, take it all away 
 Make believe that it meant something 
 Why would I want a photographic memory 
 Of somewhere that I shouldn’t be?   
 Soundtrack gone amnesiac 
 The soft whispers soaked into my skin 
 And a hard shell grew on top of them 
 Selective aphantasia 
 Can’t take us back from strangers 
 To that old Cleveland Park apartment   
 Yeah, yeah yeah   
 If you could keep a secret 
 I would bring this moment to the grave 
 Take the time, take it all away 
 Make believe that it meant something 
 Why would I want a photographic memory 
 Of somewhere that I shouldn’t be?