You hung up the phone 
 And I asked you what was wrong 
 Your dad has come to town 
 He'd like to meet 
 I said, you don't have to see him 
 But for whatever reason, you can't tell him no 
    So we meet him at a bar 
 You were holding my hand hard 
 He ordered rum and coke 
 I can't drink either anymore 
 He hadn't seen you since the fifth grade 
 Now you're nineteen and you're five-eight 
 He said, honey, you sure look great 
 Do you get the checks I send on your birthday?   
 I would kill him 
 If you let me 
 I would kill him 
 Quick and easy 
 Your nails are digging 
 Into my knee 
 I don't know 
 How you keep smiling   
 I lovе your eyes 
 And he has thеm 
 Or you have his 
 'Cause he was first 
 I imagine my thumbs on the irises 
 Pressing in until they burst   
 I clear my throat 
 And say we ought to get home 
 He offers us a ride 
 I reply: No, that's alright 
 And when we leave 
 You feel him watching 
 So we walk a mile in the wrong direction   
 I would kill him 
 If you let me 
 I would kill him 
 Quick and easy 
 Your nails are digging 
 Into my knee 
 I don't know 
 How you keep smiling 
 I don't know 
 How you keep smiling 
 I don't know 
 How you keep smiling   
 I wanna take your face between my hands and say 
 You two are connected by a pure coincidence 
 Bound to him by blood, but baby, it's all relative 
 You've been in his fist ever since you were a kid 
 But you don't owe him shit even if he said you did 
 You don't owe him shit even if he said you did